Our team is ready to answer any questions
Book your consultation today
The Employment Appeal Tribunal has held that the rule in the Employment Tribunal Rules which obliges Tribunals to reject claims which “cannot sensibly be responded to” is wrong, and should not be applied.
Background
Rule 12(1)(b) of the Employment Tribunal Rules means that claims have to be rejected when they cannot “sensibly be responded to”. This appears to be at odds with the Employment Tribunals Act 1996 which only allows this where there has either been a hearing, or the parties have agreed to it in writing.
In this case, a claim had been submitted by solicitors acting for the Claimant, Ms Parry. However, the solicitors had attached the wrong particulars of complaint. When the claim was allowed to proceed by the Tribunal, the Respondent, Williams Jones’s Schools Foundation, launched an appeal, on the basis that the claim could not “sensibly be responded to” in the form in which it was submitted.
The EAT said that the Tribunal had got it right, but for the wrong reasons. Their reasoning should have been that they had no authority, under the Employment Tribunals Act, to reject the claim without a hearing. Insofar as the Employment Tribunal Rules allowed this, they went beyond their authority, or were “ultra vires”.
Implications
Incomplete or incoherent claims cannot now be rejected without a hearing.
This judgment also calls into question further rules, requiring Tribunals to reject claims where the early conciliation process has not been completed. We expect to see challenges where claims have been rejected for failure to comply with early conciliation without agreement or a hearing.
To speak to a qualified employment solicitor at Springhouse Solicitors, fill in the form below or call 0800 915 7777.
Please note we are unable to offer free advice.
Thank you for getting in touch. A member of the team will get back to you as soon as possible.
Address:
Holborn Gate, 330 High Holborn, London, WC1V 7QH
Tel: 0800 915 7777
Thank you for subscribing. We will keep you updated with all the latest news from Springhouse Solicitors.
Copyright: Kilgannon & Partners LLP